Skip to Content
Rexburg Missing Children

Judge rules Chad Daybell case can proceed to trial

Chad Daybell in court Tuesday August 4 2020
Chad Daybell appears in court Tuesday, August 4, 2020.
Chad Daybell enters courtroom on day 2 of preliminary hearing
Chad Daybell at day 2 of his preliminary hearing.
Chad Daybell and John Prior enter courtroom day 2 hearing
Chad Daybell and attorney John Prior enter the courtroom for day 2 of Chad's preliminary hearing.
Grandparents Kay and Larry Woodcock arriving at the Fremont County Courthouse for day 2 of Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing
JJ's grandparents Kay and Larry Woodcock arriving at the Fremont County Courthouse for day 2 of Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing.
Witness Melanie Gibb enters the Fremont County Courthouse Tuesday for Chad Daybell hearing.
Witness Melanie Gibb enters the Fremont County Courthouse Tuesday for Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing.
Melanie Gibb in court day 2
Witness Melanie Gibb takes the stand for day 2 of Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing.
David Warwick witness Chad Daybell hearing
Witness David Warwick took the stand Tuesday during Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing.
Jared Scott Willmore of the Madison County Sheriff's Office then took the stand
Jared Scott Willmore of the Madison County Sheriff's Office then took the stand on Tuesday during Chad Daybells preliminary hearing.
JJ's grandparents Kay and Larry Woodcock appear in court at Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing Tuesday.
JJ's grandparents Kay and Larry Woodcock appear in court at Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing Tuesday.
FBI Special Agent Steve Daniels was then called to the witness stand.
FBI Special Agent Steve Daniels was sworn in as a witness Tuesday during the second day of Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing.
Bruce Mattingly of the Fremont County Sheriff's Office called to the witness stand during Chad Daybell preliminary hearing Tuesday.
Bruce Mattingly of the Fremont County Sheriff's Office was called to the witness stand during Chad Daybell preliminary hearing Tuesday.
Joseph Powell of the Fremont County Sheriff's Office and Bruce Mattingly of the Fremont County Sheriff's Office called to the witness stand during Chad Daybell preliminary hearing Tuesday.
Joseph Powell of the Fremont County Sheriff's Office and Bruce Mattingly of the Fremont County Sheriff's Office was called to the witness stand during Chad Daybell preliminary hearing Tuesday.
Gary Lyu who is an FBI forensic examiner was called to the witness stand Tuesday druing Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing.
Gary Lyu, who is an FBI forensic examiner, was called to the witness stand Tuesday during Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing.
FBI intelligence analyst Benjamin Dean then took the stand Tuesday during Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing.
FBI intelligence analyst Benjamin Dean took the stand Tuesday during Chad Daybell's preliminary hearing.
Judge Faren Eddins has found probable cause was shown and there is probable or sufficient cause to believe that Chad Daybell
After a two-day preliminary hearing, Judge Faren Eddins has found probable cause was shown and there is probable or sufficient cause to believe that Chad Daybell committed counts one through four as designated in the amended criminal complaint.
Grandparents Kay and Larry Woodcock seen behind Chad Daybell as judge rules case will go to district court
JJ's grandparents Kay and Larry Woodcock are seen behind Chad Daybell reacting to the news as judge rules case will go to district court.

FREMONT COUNTY, Idaho (KIFI/KIDK) - The Chad Daybell case will likely go to trial.

After two days of evidence and testimony from more than 10 witnesses, Judge Faren Eddins has found probable cause was shown and there is probable or sufficient cause to believe that Chad Daybell committed counts one through four as designated in the amended criminal complaint.

Daybell is charged with two felony counts of conspiracy to commit destruction, alteration or concealment of evidence and two felony counts of destruction, alteration or concealment of evidence.

You can watch the judge's ruling below.

Daybell has been bound to the district court. An arraignment has been set for August 21 at 9 a.m.

You can watch the preliminary hearing below.

Prosecutors on Monday began sketching out their evidence against a couple at the center of a bizarre case of two missing children whose bodies were later unearthed in rural Idaho, offering potential new details in an investigation with ties to doomsday beliefs and other mysterious deaths that captivated worldwide attention.

Daybell, 52, is charged with concealing evidence by destroying or hiding the bodies of 7-year-old Joshua "JJ" Vallow and 17-year-old Tylee Ryan at his eastern Idaho home. Investigators found their remains during a search in June, months after the kids were last seen in September.

Daybell late last year married the kids' mom, Lori Vallow Daybell, who's charged with conspiring to help him keep the bodies hidden and faces the same hearing next week. Both have pleaded not guilty.

On Tuesday, witness Melanie Gibb was the first to take the stand to be cross-examined by attorney John Prior.

Gibb said she lied to an officer and said she had JJ in her custody when she had not.

Gibb was questioned about her relationship with Chad, Lori and the kids, when she met them, how often they talked and if she thought ofLlori as a sister.

The defense also questioned Gibb's talks with Gilbert police and the FBI. There was quite a bit of back and forth especially when Chad's lawyer asked about the last time Melanie Gibb saw JJ.

Gibb's boyfriend David Warwick then took the stand. He has known Daybell for about five years.

Jared Scott Willmore of the Madison County Sheriff's Office then took the stand.

FBI Special Agent Steve Daniels was then called to the witness stand.

You can view a recap of day 2 morning's hearing below.

After the court took a recess for lunch, attorney John Prior began questioning Agent Daniels.

Joseph Powell and Bruce Mattingly both of the Fremont County Sheriff's Office then took the stand.

Next to be called to the stand was Gary Lyu who is an FBI forensic examiner.

FBI intelligence analyst Benjamin Dean then took the stand.

During Tuesday's hearing, Lori Vallow Daybell and Chad Daybell were heard in a jailhouse recording speaking by telephone to each other on the day authorities found their bodies on Daybell's property.

The recording was among nearly 30 pieces of evidence prosecutors have submitted that will be used by a judge to decide whether there is enough evidence to proceed to trial.

"I love you so much," Chad Daybell said in the recording after telling Lori Daybell police were searching the field behind the house.

"I love you," Lori Daybell responds. "Should I try to call you later?

"I don't know," Chad Daybell said. "You can try."

Day 1 Recap

Throughout the hearing Monday, we heard the details from several detectives on how they uncovered the evidence that eventually led them to find the remains of missing kids Tylee Ryan and JJ Vallow.

Detective Ray Dennis Hermosillo, Ron Ball and detective David Stubbs all of the Rexburg Police Department took the stand.

Brigham Young University Idaho Dean of Students Wynn Hill and Chad Daybell's closest friend Melanie Gibb were then called as a witness

Gibb ended Monday's testimony by speaking about her relationship with Lori and Chad.

Prosecutors played a recording that Gibb did on her own to get evidence for the police to prove that she had nothing to do with this.

During the call, Lori told Gibb, "It sounds like you've been influenced by somebody dark."

Monday was the first day of the hearing, which is expected to last two days. The judge plans to rule at the end whether there is sufficient evidence to go to trial.

Authorities haven't yet said how the children died or who caused their deaths. Court documents suggest JJ was buried in a pet cemetery on Chad Daybell's property and that Tylee's remains were dismembered and burned. Investigators found the bodies by tracking the movements of Lori's brother, Alex Cox, using cellphone data.

Cox is also dead, succumbing to an apparent blood clot in his lung at his Arizona home last December. Police Lt. Ron Ball in the small town of Rexburg, Idaho, wrote in court documents that Cox also was involved in the conspiracy to hide the kids' remains.

Court documents in Lori Daybell's criminal case include claims that the couple believed dark spirits, or "zombies," would possess people. Melanie Gibb said her friend Lori told her at different times last year that both children had become zombies and that the couple believed the only way to rid a person of a dark spirit was by killing them so the person could be at rest in the afterlife.

The strange case began last summer with Cox shooting and killing Lori's estranged husband, Charles Vallow, in suburban Phoenix in what he asserted was self-defense. Vallow had been seeking a divorce, saying Lori believed she had become a god-like figure who was responsible for ushering in the biblical end times.

A short time later, Lori and the kids moved to Idaho, where Chad Daybell lived. He ran a small publishing company and had written many fiction books about apocalyptic scenarios loosely based on the theology of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints. Friends said he claimed to be able to receive visions from "beyond the veil."

At the time, Chad Daybell was married to Tammy Daybell. She died in October of what her obituary said were natural causes. But authorities grew suspicious when Chad Daybell married Lori just two weeks later, ordering Tammy's body exhumed last December in Utah for further investigation. The results of that autopsy have not yet b een released.

Police began searching for Tylee and JJ in November after relatives raised concerns, and they soon discovered that both children were last seen in September. Police say the Daybells lied to investigators about the children's whereabouts before quietly leaving Idaho. They were found in Hawaii months later.

The case has drawn so much attention that Madison County Prosecutor Rob Wood recently hired a public relations firm to handle the influx of media requests his office receives. But the investigation isn't over, so authorities have not given details on exactly what they believe happened.

At least some of those details will likely be discussed in court this week, with three FBI agents and an Idaho State Police forensic specialist subpoenaed to testify.

Chad Daybell's defense attorney, John Prior, also will get a chance to argue his side. Neither the couple nor their lawyers have spoken publicly about the case so far.

In most preliminary hearings, defense attorneys try to show the judge that prosecutors' evidence is not strong enough to justify sending the case to trial.

Daybell is being held on $1 million bail.

Lori Vallow Daybell's preliminary hearing is scheduled for August 10 and 11. She is being held on $1,150,000 bail on charges in Fremont and Madison Counties.

You can view a timeline of events and all our past stories on Chad Daybell and Lori Vallow Daybell HERE.

Galleries / Local News / News / Rexburg / Top Stories / Videos

News Team

Associated Press

Comments

1 Comment

  1. WOW! So….after what a non-lawyer would see as a PREPONDERANCE of evidence that this creature is guilty, a judge agrees that ‘….the case will likely go to trial’. I find THIS legalized nonsense to be ALMOST as repugnant as the crime itself!
    THIS is exempli of WHY–as the perpetual whine of lawyers states–‘our’ judicial system is ‘clogged’.
    Although I personally would execute this pair of creatures, simply to rid the earth of then, I WILL concede that–based on the American system of ‘justice’–a TRIAL would be reasonable. However, the utter inanity of the endless motions, hearings, postponements, (soon to be) appeals, etc. defiles even the most BASIC definition of ‘justice’. It is NOT ‘insane’ (a ‘legal terminology’ in itself); it is just plain ******* STUPID!
    My opinion is–as has happened with COUNTLESS horrors such as this–there will likely BE no ‘trial’, but rather a Plea Agreement (BARGAIN!) which will be egregiously disappointing to everybody save the lawyers involved. BOTH sides, BTW! 🙁

Leave a Reply

Skip to content